主题:【原创】说说城管 -- 狼舞
辩护律师说的很清楚,在危险地区【就是随时可能被枪打,以至于6响左轮火力不够,要换更大火力的】执勤的警察,遇到有危险动作的人,有权开枪……显然陪审团也同意……
最后不过是重复了我早先的结论——在美国,遇到警察盘查,你首先要亮出空的双手,然后说证件在口袋里,请你来翻——这个是当地警察和民众大量鲜血证明的……
中美两国民间持枪状态是完全不同的,警察的反应也完全不同,生搬硬套大可不必……
所以我说该例子不恰当,毕竟本朝城管大人们没有生活在一个几乎人均一枪的地方……
*********************
补:
从法庭辩论看,什么没有明示自己是警察啊,没有明确命令啊,统统是某人在故意乱说,真实是:
Members of the jury, the evidence will show that a few hours earlier, while on that same patrol but before the tragic event, prior to arriving in the vicinity of 1147 Wheeler Sean and his fellow officers stopped the person who they believed was a suspect in a homicide. They required him to identify himself, which he did. It turned out they had the wrong person. They apologized to him and they walked away.
……
The officers identified themselves with their shields out, as they are trained to do and as they do in every situation. Mr. Diallo doesn't listen to their clear orders to stop, which they are trained to give. He runs back into the vestibule. More orders to stop and to show his hands. "Show us your hands," something the officers are trained to do for their own protection.
Again, Mr. Diallo does not comply. The officers pursue him with weapons drawn, as they are trained to do. He turns his back to them and runs for the inner door and tries to enter the building. He reaches into his Docket. He turns quickly towards the officers and he extends his hand forward with a black object.
Members of the jury, we believe that the evidence will show that had Mr. Diallo stopped to answer the officer's questions, like the fellow that they had an encounter with about an hour before, the whole thing would have ended peaceably moments later and we wouldn't be here.
Now, ladies and gentlemen, we are going to prove to you what was going through Sean Carroll's mind as he sees this reaction from Mr. Diallo and as he sees the series of events unfold and the black object coming out of Mr. Diallo's pocket toward him. His training is going through his mind. His experience is going through his mind. He is full of fear. And we will prove to you, ladies and gentlemen, exactly what was going on in his mind, because he verbalized it. When the black object came out of Mr. Diallo's pocket in that dimly lit vestibule, he yelled, "Gun!"
- 相关回复 上下关系8
压缩 2 层
🙂嘿嘿,黑暗的地方大家都有 lanchong 字82 2008-01-21 07:15:00
🙂啧啧,这么快就祭出了网络辩论终极武器? Alarm 字16 2008-01-21 07:50:14
🙂任何被公开的都只是冰山的一角 lanchong 字222 2008-01-21 16:02:58
🙂警察开枪合理合法,某人就不要再故意误导了
🙂一个问题 龙骨 字250 2008-01-16 20:17:32
🙂两种做法都试一下 feng 字14 2008-01-20 17:10:53
🙂去仔细看那个庭审记录……不要被骗……人家先出示警徽的 1 正版松鼠妖 字848 2008-01-16 20:26:12
🙂那就没啥奇怪的了 龙骨 字5 2008-01-16 21:56:32