主题:【原创】乱评几位评书艺术家 -- 北京胡同串子
Can't agree more!
Well, actually, Liu Lanfang's YueFeiZhuan came the first, from early 1979 to early 1980, if I remember correctly. Then came Shan Tianfang's SuiTang YanYi, from 1980 to 1981. Then Liu's Yuefei got re-broadcast in 81 or 82.
Yuan Kuocheng's ZhuJiaZhuang and ShenZhouLei were aired at about the same time that Shan's Suitang was.
I think Shan's version of Suitang in 80-81 (aired by TangShan Radio Station) is the very best among all Suitang versions. And I really don't understand why Shan edited his 80-81 version into the current version, which is so plain and bland...
Shan's 3-kindom sucks... Hate to say this but that's the fact.
Yuan's two re-arranged Shuihu stories are of great quality, although it requires significant editing work be done to make them true masterpieces. I think I wrote a thread about Yuan's Zhujiazhuang and Shenzhoulei here on this forum.
Great to know that so many people listened to and got fascinated to the great story-tellings 20+ years back... Guys, stay tuned and let's share those memories.
- 相关回复 上下关系8
单的白眉: 土豆王老五 字140 2004-09-21 03:22:45
😂确是如此, 假如适时打住, 也就不错 西柠 字0 2004-09-21 19:03:50
😜土豆土豆,我是地瓜 燕人狂徒 字0 2004-09-21 03:49:49
Great comments!
不知道王刚是否也算一家呢 马伯庸 字36 2004-09-19 22:33:19
王刚太有才了,象是天生的。 北京胡同串子 字66 2004-09-20 08:04:15
当年每到中午播刘兰芳的岳飞和杨家将的时候,街上都没人,家家户户 一笑 字80 2004-09-19 08:09:47
那恐怕跟当时能享受到的其他娱乐太少有关 早生华发 字72 2004-11-27 08:55:36