主题:【原创】G20关于俄罗斯的两部分,根本没有谴责一说。 -- nanimarcusboy
Q1. 俄罗斯侵略乌克兰了吗?
A1. 毫无疑问,是的。而且俄罗斯也承认了这一点。因为他在G20文本上签字了。
这是俄罗斯的妥协。
Q2 俄罗斯在G20受到谴责了吗?
A2.基于我的立场, 没有。为什么说没有,看看这句话的用词,是deplore而不是condemn.
这两个词语义上有微妙的区别。
We reiterated our national positions as expressed in other fora, including the UN Security Council and the UN General Assembly, which, in Resolution No. ES-11/1 dated 2 March 2022, as adopted by majority vote (141 votes for, 5 against, 35 abstentions, 12 absent) deplores in the strongest terms the aggression by the Russian Federation against Ukraine and demands its complete and unconditional withdrawal from the territory of Ukraine.
以下内容来自:
https://www.askdifference.com/condemn-vs-deplore/#:~:text=Condemn%20verb%20%28transitive%29%20To%20judicially%20pronounce%20%28someone%29%20guilty.,people%20deplore%20the%20actions%20of%20the%20corrupt%20government.%E2%80%99%3B
Condemn
verb
(transitive) [B]To strongly criticise or denounce; to excoriate the perpetrators of.[B]
‘The president condemned the terrorists.’;
(transitive) [B]To judicially pronounce (someone) guilty.[B]
(transitive) [B]To confer eternal divine punishment upon.[B]
Deplore
verb
(transitive) [B]To bewail; to weep bitterly over; to feel sorrow for.[B]
‘I deplore my neighbour for having lost his job.’; ‘
The UNHCR deplores the recent events in Sudan.’; ‘
I deplore not having listened to your advice.’;
(transitive) [B]To condemn; to express strong disapproval of.[B]
‘I deplore how you treated him at the party.’;
‘Many people deplore the actions of the corrupt government.’;
[B](obsolete) To regard as hopeless; to give up.[B]
用词的委婉应该也是俄罗斯签字妥协的一个原因。
我们中国政府翻译为“痛惜”很明确的表达了我们的立场,即侵略不对,但是事出有因。
用大白话说,“二毛,大毛打你是不对的,但你个二货得想想为啥打你。”
当然,deplore 这个词有没有谴责的意思,这就完全是基于立场的各取所需。你认为有,取的是[B]To condemn; to express strong disapproval of.[B]的解释。我认为没有,取的是[B]To bewail; to weep bitterly over; to feel sorrow for.[B]的解释。在文本中用这个词而不是condemn就是一种折中和妥协。
- 相关回复 上下关系8
🙂【讨论】事实,立场,妥协
🙂你引用的 G20 声明,核心就是一句 6 潜望镜 字403 2022-11-25 08:27:27
🙂那个谴责只是描述成员国的态度,并不是G20这个组织的态度。 10 nanimarcusboy 字311 2022-11-23 22:41:57
🙂是的 2 江阔云低 字93 2022-11-24 05:21:01
🙂这个声明有中文版的呀。 19 哎哟 字2283 2022-11-23 01:23:29