主题：【原创】普通感冒能治吗？送给无知的人们 -- 虽远必诛
家园 做过了，negtive 家园 这事有具体出处吗？挺感兴趣的 家园 自己看 1,Dowling HF, Jackson GG, Spiesman IG, Inouye T (1958). "Transmission of the common cold to volunteers under controlled conditions. III. The effect of chilling of the subjects upon susceptibility". American journal of hygiene 68 (1): 59–65. PMID 13559211.
2,Eccles R (2002). "Acute cooling of the body surface and the common cold". Rhinology 40 (3): 109–14. PMID 12357708.
3,Douglas, R.G.Jr, K.M. Lindgren, and R.B. Couch (1968). "Exposure to cold environment and rhinovirus common cold. Failure to demonstrate effect". New Engl. J. Med 279.
4,Douglas RC, Couch RB, Lindgren KM (1967). "Cold doesn't affect the "common cold" in study of rhinovirus infections". JAMA 199 (7): 29–30. doi:10.1001/jama.199.7.29. PMID 4289651
- 复 自己看
家园 很难看文章内容 最多是abstract，所以具体实验方法也不得而知。不过看到另外一个，2005年发表的
http://fampra.oxfordjournals.org/cgi/reprint/22/6/608
结论是
Acute chilling of the feet causes the onset of common cold symptoms in around 10% of subjects who are chilled. Further studies are needed to determine the relationship of symptom generation to any respiratory infection.再者，从中医角度说，人在“神完气足”的情况下，可以寒暑不侵。在我看来，在一个“神完气足”的人身上，直接找cold exposure-common cold的因果关系没有意义。又如，实际生活中，天气一变，儿科那里肯定就忙。也就是普通人常说的，小孩子身子弱，容易着凉生病。
- 复 很难看文章内容
家园 如果想深入研究，就要去直接看那些原始文献。 There is a widely held belief that acute viral respiratory infections are the result of a "chill" and that the onset of a respiratory infection such as the common cold is often associated with acute cooling of the body surface, especially as the result of wet clothes and hair. However, experiments involving inoculation of common cold viruses into the nose, and periods of cold exposure, have failed to demonstrate any effect of cold exposure on susceptibility to infection with common cold viruses. Present scientific opinion dismisses any cause-and-effect relationship between acute cooling of the body surface and common cold.你用的这片文献也没有认为同普通感冒有关，１０％的类似症状，应当是对寒冷的血管痉挛导致的。
另外你说“神完气足”也就是没有直接接触病毒，或者对某种病毒有免疫。当然同温差没有关系。
冬天儿科忙，考虑病毒的传染性是从人到人，一个有病，相当于培养了病毒，非常容易传染给他人。
着凉同普通感冒没有关系是定论。
家园 还是有点说道 In summary the results of the present study support the folklore that exposure to chilling may cause the onset of common cold symptoms,perhaps by some change in respiratory defense caused by reflex vasoconstriction of the blood vessels of the upper airways. Further studies in this area are needed to determine if the development of common cold symptoms following cold exposure are associated with infection.文章至少把冷和症状联系起来了，但是不认同有cause-and-effect的结论。按西医认识，cause只会是病菌，病毒啥的。我倒是觉得有可能就是冷改变了一些人的体内环境，导致一些共生的细菌的过度繁殖，引发炎症。如果这种可能性存在，那么病菌什么的可以算是标因，寒可算是一个本因。我想可以做这么个实验，让实验对象在无菌房呆着，升高房间温度一阵，让受试者出点汗，然后用低温做点温度实验，一周后再出来看症状。看看冷与感冒症状间的关系。
家园 请教一下虽远医生 作为一个乙肝携带者，我了解到抗病毒的药物不是没有，但是好像不能真正治好任何一种病毒导致的疾病。是不是这些药物杀不绝病毒？
家园 感冒中，那天爬楼12层，一身汗，进了办公室脱大衣，冷 一天没暖和过来，然后就感冒了，每次都是从喉咙肿痛开始~~~~~~~~~~~~~
没办法，难受啊