主题:中华文明起源辨(上) -- 黄金狮子
wikipedia
The term civilization has been defined and understood in a number of ways different from the standard definition. Sometimes it is used synonymously with the broader term culture. Civilization can also refer to society as a whole. To nineteenth-century English anthropologist Edward Burnett Tylor, for example, civilization was "the total social heredity of mankind;"[3] in other words, civilization was the totality of human knowledge and culture as represented by the most "advanced" society at a given time.[4] Civilization can be used in a normative sense as well: if complex and urban cultures are assumed to be superior to other "savage" or "barbarian" cultures, then "civilization" is used as a synonym for "superiority of certain groups." In a similar sense, civilization can mean "refinement of thought, manners, or taste".[5] However, in its most widely used definition, civilization is a descriptive term for a relatively complex agricultural and urban culture.
你说得,其实不是"文明"的标准的,运用最广泛的定义。
现在,在历史学,考古学,社会学上提到的"文明",完全不涉及价值判断,不是野蛮的反义词。
洋人,对他们当初的行为,早就有过反思,电影与狼共舞里面表述的就是:"野蛮"的印第安人,道德比美国"文明"人高多了。这点,我想,象老兄这么爱国的人不会否认吧!
那么,有着5000年的文明史的中国人,在5000年前就摆脱野蛮了吗?
嘿嘿,鲁迅说,他在史书上只看到吃人二字;
我们悠久完备的法律体系里,嫌疑犯不招供,一般要拖下去打个80大板,再问他招不招.......
老兄既然写的是学术文章,建议还是修改一下文明的定义。
- 相关回复 上下关系8
🙂中华文明起源辨(上) 36 黄金狮子 字5724 2008-01-07 03:10:49
🙂二里头一个缺憾就是没有发现文字纪录说“老子就是夏!” 九霄环珮 字48 2008-01-08 19:58:30
🙂历史和考古现在被视为一种科学,一种社会科学 九霄环珮 字276 2008-01-08 19:04:54
😥civilization是什么意思?
🙂您要质疑LZ文中“文明”的含义,不如先把自己的话说圆了 2 毛锥子 字624 2008-01-08 10:20:25
🙂很高兴又在新年里见面了 1 AleaJactaEst 字610 2008-01-08 10:34:48
🙂回复“civilization是什么意思” 6 黄金狮子 字1815 2008-01-07 23:40:48
🙂请问真有洋历史学家认为中国不配四大文明古国? 九霄环珮 字102 2008-01-08 19:18:02