主题:发现程序问题的漏洞是解救任大小姐的关键 -- 龙眼
Paul Wolf
18小时前
(已被编辑)
There is the presumption against extraterritorial application of US laws, and also the question of jurisdiction over her case. She is a Chinese citizen and anything that she did wrong, she did in China. The case has no contacts at all with the US. China should make its own extradition request, so that Ms. Wanzhou can be tried in a Chinese court. A Canadian judge considering two competing extradition requests would have to determine which country has a greater interest in the case.
Although its doubtful that violating US sanctions against Iran is a crime in China, she's also accused of making false statements on bank loan applications, which probably is. (fraud) Even if the case against her is weak, she will be badly mistreated and imprisoned for years until it's resolved.
喜欢thumb_up
回复reply
Linklink
举报flag
这个说法理说清楚了。美方指控孟欺诈违反美国的伊朗制裁案,可是孟是中国公民,该行为是在中国香港实行的,对方是香港based的英资银行。和美国与加拿大都没有连接点!连接点是国际法里非常重要的概念,也是管辖权能行使的关键。美国主张的是英资的汇丰银行被自己处罚,那是英国认可美国司法部的管辖。TMD中国认可了你美国对香港管辖了吗?认可你对中国境内中国公司的管辖了吗?还是中国认可了美国对中国境内个人的管辖了?还是中国人认可了英国认可的冲突规则对中国的管辖了?都没有!都没有,就根本没有连接点!这里是伪造一个链接点——美国因为汇丰银行的处罚,而去管辖汇丰银行的一个中国客户!
- 相关回复 上下关系8
🙂据传加拿大孟宅遭人闯入还是被强行搜查,要啥证据都能搞出来 白浪滔天 字81 2018-12-10 07:20:30
🙂突然觉得龙眼兄得学学中国近代史 2 审度 字202 2018-12-10 05:37:38
🙂都给钱,让青楼女脱衣和让占街女脱衣有何不同? 5 龙眼 字276 2018-12-10 11:14:36
🙂有一个提出管辖权问题的美国评论,见下
🙂A国用国内法在B国抓了C国人,本身就是霸权主义。 11 友来有趣 字463 2018-12-09 23:12:35
🙂讨论前最好先补一些法律常识,了解一下比如说长臂法。 ErgoSum 字0 2018-12-10 04:33:46
🙂国际法上并没有全面承认长臂管辖,中国也主张长臂管辖 10 瀚海黄沙 字1174 2018-12-10 04:43:50
🙂对事管辖也是可以用国家利益为判断依据的 ErgoSum 字270 2018-12-10 04:48:54